DVD Extras for Editors….

The Best DVD Extras For Film Editors

Personally I love it when filmmakers cram their dvd releases with as many extras as they can. Here are a few of my favourites, in no particular order or preference which focus on film editors and film editing…

Se7en Commentaries

There are four commentaries to choose from on Se7en, the best being the two production orientated ones, including editor Richard Francis-Bruce. All are worth a look, as is the ‘mastering for home theatre’ which features an early colour correction walk through by prominent colorist Stephen Nakamura.

 Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk

Lord of the Rings : The Two Towers

22 minutes of inside info on the editing of the epic trilogy, with the various editors under Peter Jackson’s portly helm. All 12 discs of the entire extended edition are well worth the effort, provided you’ve got a spare 60 hours. And that’s just each extended film once through and then 4 more times for each of the commentaries…not to mention actually sitting down to watch the extra features….

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk

The Social Network

An excellent dvd with a feature length making of the film, plus thoughts from Angus Wall, Kirk Baxter and Ren Klyce on the post process. Great stuff on the emotional intricacies of story, flow and working with Fincher.

Buy on Amazon.co.uk | Buy on Amazon.com


Best dvd commentaries for film editorsSwingers is a great film, not only for it’s br0mance wit and quotable lines (”You always double down on 11″) but also for the fact that the special edition DVD comes with two commentaries and a whole host of making of films. The commentary that made me buy it though was the excellent pairing of director Doug Liman and editor Stephen Mirrione. Mirrione has cut a huge raft of brilliant films including Traffic, 21 Grams, The Ides of March, Confessions of a Dangerous Mind and many more. It’s great hearing him describe all of the ways he had to ‘break the rules’ to make a low-budget first feature work.

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk

Cold Mountain

Cold mountain dvd extras

Cold Mountain’s making of documentary (70 minutes) featuring a good amount of legendary editor Walter Murch. Also worth a look is the book ‘Behind the seen‘ which tracks Murch using Final Cut Pro for the first time on a hollywood feature.

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk

Panic Room 3 Disc Special Edition

behind the scenes extras for film editors

David Fincher’s Panic Room, is not his best film, but I love it’s tone and aesthetic. In the three disc special edition DVD there is a treasure trove of filmmaking behind the scenes treats.

The bonus discs include camera and lighting tests from Conrad Hall, practical effects tests, pre-vis, an hour long documentary on shooting the film, visual effects breakdowns and more. On top of that there are three feature length commentaries from Fincher, an actors commentary and a commentary from writer David Koepp who is joined by William Goldman.

Panic Room is also the ‘most pre-vis’d’ film in history (up to it’s production date that is!) and you get to sit in on a pre-vis review session as Fincher re-works his shots.

If you’re a fan of David Fincher you need to check out this seriously great behind the scenes movie making gold.

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk


All of the extras on Gareth Edwards inspiringly small production, Monsters, are definitely worth a watch for no nonsense, no guff, practical film making insight.

Buy on Amazon.com

Buy on Amazon.co.uk


Traffic DVD Extras for Film Editors

Possibly one of director Steven Soderbergh’s best films the Criterion 2 disc dvd and blu-ray release features 3 feature commentaries, 25 deleted scenes with commentary plus 3 inside looks at creating the Mexico film processing style, dialogue editing and crucially editor Stephen Mirrione talking about cutting the film. You can’t ask for better than that.

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk (Region 1, US import)

King Kong

King Kong Making of

35 post production diaries from the making of Peter Jackson’s King Kong, meticulously covering all aspects of the post work. 2 hours and 40 minutes of fun.

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk


When you listen to the commentary from director Christopher Nolan he takes the interesting approach of showing the movie in its production schedule order, which helps give a different angle on the editorial process.

Buy on Amazon.comBuy on Amazon.co.uk


Magnolia Making of Paul Thomas AndersonI’m a big fan of Paul Thomas Anderson and this 2 disc edition of the masterful Magnolia contains a feature length making of that provides pretty much unfettered access to PTA and many of the other cast and crew.

There are some great moments with PTA discussing scenes with the actors as well as production insights like how late in the day PTA wrote the content for the TV show within the film. Although not strictly about post-production, it is a great lesson in filmmaking from one of America’s developing master filmmakers.

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk

The English Patient

‘A conversation’ with Walter Murch’ is a sampling of short interview material with Murch, focusing on his relationship with director Anthony Minghella but also the technical process of putting the film together. Plenty of other good stuff on the Special Edition disc too.

Buy on Amazon.com

Buy on Amazon.co.uk


Memento's timeline - dvd extras for film editors

Memento is really the film that made Christopher Nolan, and it’s well worth repeat viewings, especially along with his audio commentary (which as a random aside, includes this unmotivated giggle).  The special edition dvd also affords the opportunity to watch the film in chronological order, which does help to make it make a lot more sense, but that sort of takes the fun out of it. Still a great lesson in creative film structure.

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk

Erin Brockovich

Erin BrokovichDeleted scenes commentary (and an odd ‘music only’ audio option) from director Steven Soderbergh, which provides some useful insights into what to chop out when you’ve got to get the movie down to time.

Buy on Amazon.com | Buy on Amazon.co.uk


Leave a Comment